[Map](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/) / [Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th039-moduli-degeneration-and-abelian-scheme-laws/) / k1611

Cluster k1611 · Lean proof of the Riemann hypothesis

# Crystalline comparison for Harris-Taylor models, stated as named hypotheses

Abelian varieties · 1980s · PhD level

About 80 files, all in a folder named for annihilator models and "crystalline comparison" (a link between two ways of describing p-adic torsion). Nearly every file is a definition of type Prop, meaning a named claim that is stated but not proved here, such as a claim about injectivity on etale models, or about a generic point staying generic after a flat map. Theorems then take a chain of these claims as assumptions and conclude another claim, so the cluster is mostly a network of "if these hold, then this holds" implications. The topic is isogenies (maps with finite kernel) between abelian varieties with ring action over a discrete valuation ring (a ring with one prime).

[5 import steps to the main theorem.](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k0677-main-theorem-statements-plus-the-explicit-formula-for/)

Feeds into 12 clusters · under 1% of the map.

Proof status as of 22 Nov 2026: on 21 Nov 2026 a [joint statement](https://leanprover-community.github.io/blog/posts/riemann-hypothesis/) by the Lean and Mathlib communities, endorsed by the Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative, certified the Lean statement and proof. More independent checks: [math.mit.edu/~drew/grh](https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/). Names and descriptions on this map are written by Claude from samples of the code and may be wrong.

## Why it's in the proof

- This cluster: Crystalline comparison for Harris-Taylor models, stated as named hypotheses
- [Harris-Taylor integral models, first-order points and tangent lifts](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1941-harris-taylor-integral-models-first-order-points-and/) — Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties
- [Poincaré de Rham duality, cube theorem and p-divisible group statements](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1948-poincare-de-rham-duality-cube-theorem-and-p-divisible-group/) — Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties
- [Cuspidal spectrum, trace class and published representation theory](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1883-cuspidal-spectrum-trace-class-and-published-representation/) — Theta lifts and the trace formula on unitary groups
- [Mertens-type estimates and zero sums for Dirichlet L-functions](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k0694-mertens-type-estimates-and-zero-sums-for-dirichlet-l/) — Hecke characters and primes in progressions
- [★ Main theorem: Main theorem statements, plus the explicit formula for Dirichlet L-functions](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k0677-main-theorem-statements-plus-the-explicit-formula-for/)

Each step is an import. This is 1 of 2 shortest routes.

## Prerequisite concepts

Schemes: spaces glued from rings (Spec, Zariski topology), Discrete valuation rings: numbers with one prime, and reducing mod it, Valuation rings and lattices over them, Etale ring maps (extensions without branching), Dedekind domains (unique factorisation of ideals), Group schemes: tori, abelian varieties and torsion points, p adic numbers, Ideals, ideal norm and discriminant of a number field

## References

Harris and Taylor, The Geometry and Cohomology of Some Simple Shimura Varieties · ch. III-IV — Background reading suggested by the AI namer · unchecked

## Builds on 18 clusters

Direct imports: clusters with a file that a file here imports.

By theme: [Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th039-moduli-degeneration-and-abelian-scheme-laws/) (13), [Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th047-coherent-cohomology-on-abelian-varieties/) (2), [Crystalline–semistable comparison and Witt lattices](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th034-crystallinesemistable-comparison-and-witt-lattices/) (1), [Étale cohomology: sheaves, purity and Kummer theory](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th008-etale-cohomology-sheaves-purity-and-kummer-theory/) (1), [Toroidal compactifications of Siegel and unitary moduli](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th042-toroidal-compactifications-of-siegel-and-unitary-moduli/) (1)

Key: [Harris-Taylor / Kottwitz-Shimura moduli models and Galois descent](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1606-harris-taylor-kottwitz-shimura-moduli-models-and-galois/), [Semistable group schemes over discrete valuation rings, degeneration](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1529-semistable-group-schemes-over-discrete-valuation-rings/), [Theorem of the cube, torsion loci and the Zarhin trick](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1609-theorem-of-the-cube-torsion-loci-and-the-zarhin-trick/)

- [Grothendieck-Messing deformation and crystalline duality for abelian schemes](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1935-grothendieck-messing-deformation-and-crystalline-duality/) — Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties
- [Semistable group schemes over discrete valuation rings, degeneration](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1529-semistable-group-schemes-over-discrete-valuation-rings/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Theorem of the cube, torsion loci and the Zarhin trick](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1609-theorem-of-the-cube-torsion-loci-and-the-zarhin-trick/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Abelian scheme endomorphisms, finite flat torsion and ample rigidity](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1530-abelian-scheme-endomorphisms-finite-flat-torsion-and-ample/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Etale and finite maps, Harris-Taylor objects and torsion subschemes](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1588-etale-and-finite-maps-harris-taylor-objects-and-torsion/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Picard classes, principal polarisations and doubling on theta objects](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1583-picard-classes-principal-polarisations-and-doubling-on/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Dual abelian schemes, Poincare bundles and additive line bundles](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1604-dual-abelian-schemes-poincare-bundles-and-additive-line/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Hecke correspondence schemes and descent of Galois covers](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1542-hecke-correspondence-schemes-and-descent-of-galois-covers/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Etale level structures and torsion counts at a prime](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1565-etale-level-structures-and-torsion-counts-at-a-prime/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Semi-abelian extension and theta-system rational models](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1734-semi-abelian-extension-and-theta-system-rational-models/) — Toroidal compactifications of Siegel and unitary moduli
- [Hecke translates and Weil pairing on prime-to-p level structures](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1591-hecke-translates-and-weil-pairing-on-prime-to-p-level/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Weil pairing and cubical bundles on polarized abelian schemes](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1549-weil-pairing-and-cubical-bundles-on-polarized-abelian/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Abelian varieties: flatness, degree of isogenies and kernel size](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1947-abelian-varieties-flatness-degree-of-isogenies-and-kernel/) — Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties
- [Abelian schemes spreading out and extending over a DVR](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1579-abelian-schemes-spreading-out-and-extending-over-a-dvr/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Pullbacks and uniqueness of Harris-Taylor level objects](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1589-pullbacks-and-uniqueness-of-harris-taylor-level-objects/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Harris-Taylor / Kottwitz-Shimura moduli models and Galois descent](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1606-harris-taylor-kottwitz-shimura-moduli-models-and-galois/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Annihilator models: characteristic polynomials and splitting](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1347-annihilator-models-characteristic-polynomials-and-splitting/) — Crystalline–semistable comparison and Witt lattices
- [Étale-local conditions and cup products in cohomology](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k0180-etale-local-conditions-and-cup-products-in-cohomology/) — Étale cohomology: sheaves, purity and Kummer theory

## Needed by 3 clusters

Direct importers: clusters with a file that imports a file here.

By theme: [Crystalline–semistable comparison and Witt lattices](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th034-crystallinesemistable-comparison-and-witt-lattices/) (1), [Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th039-moduli-degeneration-and-abelian-scheme-laws/) (1), [Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th047-coherent-cohomology-on-abelian-varieties/) (1)

Key: [Harris-Taylor integral models, first-order points and tangent lifts](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1941-harris-taylor-integral-models-first-order-points-and/) (on the route to the main theorem), [Harris-Taylor / Kottwitz-Shimura moduli models and Galois descent](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1606-harris-taylor-kottwitz-shimura-moduli-models-and-galois/), [Hodge towers, local models and crystalline comparison steps](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1348-hodge-towers-local-models-and-crystalline-comparison-steps/)

- [Harris-Taylor integral models, first-order points and tangent lifts](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1941-harris-taylor-integral-models-first-order-points-and/) — Coherent cohomology on abelian varieties
- [Harris-Taylor / Kottwitz-Shimura moduli models and Galois descent](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1606-harris-taylor-kottwitz-shimura-moduli-models-and-galois/) — Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws
- [Hodge towers, local models and crystalline comparison steps](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1348-hodge-towers-local-models-and-crystalline-comparison-steps/) — Crystalline–semistable comparison and Witt lattices

82 Lean files, main folder Development.AutomorphicArithmetic.Foundations.GaloisRepresentations.AnnihilatorModels.

## Explore

- [Theme: Moduli, degeneration and abelian scheme laws](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/theme/th039-moduli-degeneration-and-abelian-scheme-laws/)
- [Start at the main theorem's cluster](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k0677-main-theorem-statements-plus-the-explicit-formula-for/)
- [How the proof is structured: the route to the main theorem](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/route/)
- [The core of the proof: 16 clusters, names checked against the code](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/core/)
- [The proof in numbers: files, lines, clusters and checks](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/proof-in-numbers/)
- [Has the Riemann hypothesis been solved? Status of the proof](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/status/)
- [Learning path: the proof step by step, down to school maths](https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/learn/)

---

Crystalline comparison for Harris-Taylor models, stated as named hypotheses. Web page: https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/cluster/k1611-crystalline-comparison-for-harris-taylor-models-stated-as/ · updated 2026-11-22 · site map for machines: https://riemannhypothesissolved.com/llms.txt
